Dutch Supreme Court Rulings on the interpretation of anti-abuse rules related to the dividend withholding tax exemption in (intermediary) holding structures (“Belgian Cases”) – practical implications and recommendations
1. Introduction to the Belgian Cases
In the landmark rulings of the Supreme Court cases of 18 July 2025 (“the Belgian cases”) the anti-avoidance provision in Article 4(3)(c) of the Dutch Dividend Withholding Tax Act was discussed. In these two cases, Belgian holding companies received dividends from a minority interest in a Dutch company, holding various portfolio investments and managed by a private-equity firm. In one case, the holding company was considered passive, in the other case the holding company had an active involvement in various investments.
The Supreme Court characterizes this case by the below facts:
- The non-Dutch resident shareholders hold interests in various other foreign and Dutch companies (hereinafter also referred to as participations) through an intermediate holding non-Dutch resident company (the interested party in this case).
- Various shareholdings operate a material business, and the intermediate holding company actively manages and directs these shareholdings.
- The other participations (including the Dutch company that is the subject of the court case) invest exclusively in portfolio investments and the intermediate holding company does not engage in any other economic activity with regard to these participations (other than passive investment).
2. Considerations by the Supreme Court
In its ruling, the Supreme Court has given further clarifications on the interpretation of the anti-abuse rules. We will highlight certain considerations of the Supreme Court below, which are the basis of our further recommendations:
- “Such an artificial step or element will be recognisable in particular if it cannot be justified by the economic and commercial advantages associated with it.” and “It is also possible that only certain steps or parts of a structure are artificial and therefore fall under this anti-abuse provision.” – This implies that each step and each element of a structure needs to be considered on its merits to determine whether the anti-abuse provision may need to be applied.
- The Supreme Court considers “facts and circumstances that indicate (i) either that the relevant step or part of the structure can be justified by, in short, valid business reasons that can be found in advantages associated with those steps or parts other than the dividend withholding tax benefit (…) (ii) or that, despite the absence of business reasons as referred to above, the relevant step or part of the structure has not been added with the main purpose or one of the main purposes of obtaining a tax advantage which undermines the purpose or intent of Article 4(2) of the Act” – Thus, each step and element should be based on valid business reasons, or should not be added (or in place) for tax purposes.
- The Supreme Court indicates that the investigation is “not limited to the facts and circumstances that occur at the time of setting up the arrangement.” and that “it cannot be ruled out that an arrangement initially conceived for commercial reasons reflecting economic reality must be regarded as artificial from a given point in time because that arrangement has been maintained despite a change in circumstances or because steps or elements have been added to it which may be regarded as artificial. Therefore, when assessing whether the construction or the relevant step or part of it is artificial, facts and circumstances that occur or have occurred after the construction of the construction can also be taken into account.” – We conclude that a structure needs to be tested continuously on business reasons, artificial elements and tax advantage purposes.
- The Supreme Court supports the conclusion that “the interposition of the interested party as a foreign company in order to hold the participation in the BV is an artificial construction that does not relate to economic reality and is aimed at avoiding the levying of Dutch dividend withholding tax on the shareholders of the interested party.” In this respect, taking into account “that the family that is a shareholder of the interested party can decide entirely at its own discretion whether or not to have the profits distributed by the BV to the interested party distributed to it or to have them used for reinvestment, and that in that sense the interested party cannot freely dispose of the dividends it receives from the BV” and adding significance to the fact “that there is no obligation for the interested party to reinvest all or part of the profits received from the BV” may be relevant to the weighing of the facts and circumstances (reference to the Danish cases).
- Furthermore, the Supreme Court reiterates that the Dutch national anti-abuse law must be interpreted consistently with the EU directive and case law.
- Finally, the Supreme Court also addresses the allocation of the burden of proof with respect to this anti-abuse article: first it is the tax inspector who must render plausible facts and circumstances that indicate that the article is applicable, and then the taxpayer can provide counter evidence that business reasons exist or that the tax motive is absent.
3. Practical implications and recommendations
As stated by the Supreme Court, a structure that is classified as not subject to the anti-avoidance rule, may involve over time to a structure that may be considered in scope of this rule. Therefore, we recommend – also considering the special attention of the Dutch tax authorities following the Belgian Cases – to reassess the facts and circumstances of structures, and if possible, to strengthen structures. In this respect, we the following structure could be considered as a solid starting point:
TopCo has relevant substance, including office space, a bank account and a board with professionals (not only trust service providers), potential with also the UBOs on the board.- InterCo – if included in the structure – has relevant substance and performs an intermediary/liaison function.
- TargetCo conducts business activities and has a board with professionals (not only trust service providers).
- TopCo has a management, policy and/or financial steering role at TargetCo through a management agreement between TopCo and TargetCo. This role is carried out by an employee of TopCo (“Manager”), who receives a salary of at least EUR 100,000. The wage costs are financially (partly) borne by TargetCo through settlement against the management fee under the management agreement.
- As a consequence, in the TargetCo jurisdiction in principle wage tax will be levied on Manager’s wages, next to a deduction of wage costs for corporate income tax purposes.
- TopCo may consider not to have a formal seat on TargetCo’s management board to prevent its directors’ liability risks regarding its involvement with TargetCo. Certain decisions (e.g. high value divestments/invests) require shareholder approval.
- Manager reports to both TargetCo (strategic business advice) and to TopCo (investment progress reports). These (written) reports are discussed in the respective board meetings (with Manager) on a periodic basis
For a tailored advice, please reach out to our team. Our experts can provide personalized guidance to ensure your structures comply with the rules formulated by the Supreme Court and are robust against scrutiny.